Shih Tzu vs Yorkshire Terrier
Choosing between a Shih Tzu and a Yorkshire Terrier feels like deciding between two very different personalities wrapped in similarly compact bodies. Both breeds fit neatly into apartments, travel bags and urban routines, yet the day‑to‑day experience of living with each one diverges dramatically once barking habits, grooming schedules, energy levels and family dynamics enter the picture. This guide is designed for first‑time small dog owners in the USA, UK, Europe, Germany, India, Australia and beyond who want an honest, practical breakdown of what each breed truly demands before bringing one home. It covers breed history, temperament, grooming workload, trainability, health risks, allergy considerations, family compatibility, long‑term costs and lifestyle matching so you can make a decision based on real compatibility rather than appearance alone. Whether you live alone in a studio, share a flat with roommates, have older children or simply want a calm companion after years without a pet, understanding these two breeds in depth will help you avoid the common regrets that come from choosing a dog based on looks rather than lifestyle fit.
Why These Two Breeds Matter
The Shih Tzu: A Royal Lapdog with Ancient Roots
The Shih Tzu traces its origins back over a thousand years to ancient China and Tibet, where it was developed as a cherished companion for emperors and nobles. The breed’s name means “Lion Dog” in traditional Chinese, a reference to its lion‑like facial features that were revered in Imperial courts because Buddha was said to have ridden to earth on the back of a lion. During the Ming and Manchu Dynasties, these little lion dogs were bred and raised by palace eunuchs and were considered the exclusive property of the royal court, rarely seen outside the palaces and so valued that anyone caught owning one outside the palace could face severe punishment.
This history of living as a pampered palace companion explains why the modern Shih Tzu is so remarkably people‑oriented, calm and content to simply be near its owner without demanding constant activity. Unlike breeds developed for hunting, herding or guarding, the Shih Tzu was bred purely for companionship and warmth, which shows in its gentle, friendly disposition and its willingness to adapt to various living situations. The breed nearly vanished during the Chinese Communist Revolution but was saved by a small number of dogs exported to England and other Western countries, from which all modern Shih Tzus descend.
The Yorkshire Terrier: From Factory Floors to Fashion Icons
Yorkshire Terriers emerged in 19th‑century northern England, developed by mill and mine workers in Yorkshire and Lancashire who needed a small, fearless ratter to control vermin in cramped industrial spaces. That working heritage still shows in modern Yorkies as boldness, persistence, a strong prey drive and an instinct to guard territory and alert to every sound in the hallway. Over time the breed shifted from rough factory companion to polished Victorian lapdog, eventually becoming a quintessential city pet that fits into handbags, public transport and tiny studios while still behaving as though it owns the building.
This terrier background is crucial for first‑time owners to understand because it explains so much about Yorkie behaviour that can otherwise seem confusing or frustrating. The same instincts that made them excellent ratters, including quick reactions, persistence, vocalization and a willingness to confront animals many times their size, can translate into barking at every noise, chasing small animals, and standing their ground against much larger dogs. Unlike the Shih Tzu, which was bred to sit quietly and be adored, the Yorkie was bred to work, react and assert itself.
Unique Appeal and Modern Roles
Both breeds have carved out strong positions in the modern pet world, but they appeal to different types of owners. Shih Tzus attract people seeking a calm, affectionate companion that does not require intense exercise or stimulation, making them particularly popular with seniors, apartment dwellers and families looking for a gentle first dog. Their reputation as excellent dogs for first‑time owners is supported by surveys showing that around 89% of experienced Shih Tzu owners recommend the breed for beginners.
Yorkshire Terriers appeal to owners who want a tiny dog with a big, expressive personality and do not mind the vocal, attention‑seeking behaviours that come with the terrier temperament. They are extremely portable, fit airline cabin requirements easily, and bond intensely with their owners, making them ideal for people who want a constant companion they can take everywhere. However, their energy, barking tendencies and sometimes bossy behaviour mean they require more management than their small size might suggest.
Strategic Fit for First‑Time Owners
For first‑time small dog owners, the choice between these breeds often comes down to energy level and noise tolerance. Shih Tzus have less energy than most other dogs and are generally quieter, with a more relaxed disposition that suits owners who want companionship without constant activity demands. Yorkshire Terriers are far more active and bark much more, requiring owners who can manage their vocal nature and channel their energy appropriately.
Both breeds require significant grooming commitment, so first‑time owners should not choose either breed expecting low maintenance. Both can be good choices for allergy‑conscious households due to their low‑shedding coats, though neither is truly hypoallergenic and individual reactions vary.
Breed Profiles in Depth
Shih Tzu: The Calm Companion
Shih Tzus are renowned for their affectionate and outgoing temperament, making them excellent family pets that thrive on human companionship. They are affectionate and playful companions known for their friendly disposition and gentle demeanor, particularly well‑suited for households with children and other pets. Despite their small size, Shih Tzus possess a confident and independent spirit, but this independence manifests as contentment rather than the demanding assertiveness seen in terrier breeds.
The typical Shih Tzu stands 8 to 11 inches tall at the shoulder and weighs between 9 and 16 pounds, making them slightly larger and sturdier than Yorkshire Terriers. This extra substance means they are somewhat less fragile and can tolerate gentle handling from children better than the delicate Yorkie. Their energy level is notably lower than most dogs, described as “low‑energy” dogs that still need regular stimulation but do not require the same level of activity as more energetic breeds.
Shih Tzus are alert and curious with a keen sense of observation that endears them to their owners, but they were not bred to be watchdogs and typically do not bark excessively at strangers or noises. They are usually very interested in people and friendly toward strangers rather than suspicious, which makes them poor guard dogs but excellent social companions. Their expressive facial features and charming personality make them delightful companions for individuals of all ages.
Yorkshire Terrier: The Bold Little Terrier
Yorkshire Terriers pack enormous personality into a tiny frame, typically weighing only 7 to 10 pounds and standing 8 to 9 inches tall at the shoulder. They are often described as “big dog in a small body,” meaning they are confident, sometimes bossy, quick to assert themselves with larger dogs, and deeply loyal to their chosen person. Their personality includes being ferocious yet lovable, brave despite their size, and intensely attached to their owners.
This breed is significantly more energetic than the Shih Tzu, with high activity levels and a need for regular physical and mental stimulation. They are quick, reactive and easily stimulated by sounds, movements and new people, which can translate into frequent barking if not managed through training. Yorkshire Terriers make excellent watchdogs due to their alertness and willingness to sound the alarm, but this same trait means they can be noisy neighbours in apartment buildings.
Yorkies tend to be suspicious of strangers and can become jealous or overprotective if they are too attached to their owners. They may be less suited for busy households with young children because they can be nippy, reactive to noise, and fragile enough to be injured by rough handling. Their terrier nature also means they have a strong prey drive and may chase small animals, cats or even challenge much larger dogs.
Temperament Comparison: Calm vs Bold
Energy Levels and Daily Activity
The difference in energy between these two breeds is one of the most important factors for first‑time owners to consider. Shih Tzus are described as low‑energy dogs that should still be stimulated on a regular basis but do not require the same level of activity as more energetic breeds. This means scheduling time for them to run around and play daily, but sessions can be shorter and less intense than what a Yorkie needs.
Yorkshire Terriers have a lot of energy and are ferocious in their approach to life, needing more frequent activity and mental engagement to stay balanced. They enjoy short bursts of intense play, interactive games, and walks that allow them to explore and investigate. Without adequate outlets, Yorkies may become restless, vocal and destructive.
For first‑time owners who work full‑time or have limited time for dog activities, the Shih Tzu’s lower energy requirements may be more manageable. Owners who enjoy active engagement, training sessions and interactive play may find the Yorkie’s energy rewarding but should be prepared for the commitment.
Barking and Noise
Barking is perhaps the most significant behavioural difference between these breeds and often the deciding factor for apartment dwellers. Yorkshire Terriers bark much more than Shih Tzus due to their terrier heritage and watchdog instincts. They are quick to alert to strangers, noises in hallways, delivery people, and any activity outside windows.
Shih Tzus bark but not nearly as much as Yorkies or most other dogs. They were developed to be the perfect companion animal and often have little reason to bark, being friendly and curious rather than suspicious and reactive. This makes them significantly easier to live with in apartments, condos and shared housing where noise complaints are a concern.
Managing Yorkie barking requires consistent training, desensitization to triggers, and realistic expectations, as many owners report that their Yorkies bark frequently despite training efforts. Some owners accept barking as part of the Yorkie experience, while others find it frustrating. First‑time owners with noise‑sensitive neighbours should seriously consider the Shih Tzu’s quieter nature.
Social Behaviour and Stranger Response
Shih Tzus are usually sociable dogs who love company and take well to meeting new people. They were bred to be charming companions in social settings and typically greet strangers with interest rather than suspicion. This friendly nature makes them easy to take to public places, introduce to visitors, and include in social situations.
Yorkshire Terriers can be suspicious of new people if they are too attached to their owners, sometimes showing jealousy or territorial behaviour. Early socialization is essential to help Yorkies develop confidence around strangers and prevent reactive behaviour. Without proper socialization, Yorkies may bark at, snap at, or avoid unfamiliar people.
For first‑time owners who entertain frequently, have regular visitors, or want a dog they can easily take to social situations, the Shih Tzu’s natural friendliness is an advantage.
Independence vs Attachment
Both breeds form strong bonds with their owners but express attachment differently. Shih Tzus are affectionate and enjoy being close to their people but can also be somewhat independent, content to relax nearby without demanding constant attention. They thrive on companionship but are generally not as clingy or demanding as some other breeds.
Yorkshire Terriers are lap dogs that want to sit on your lap and be with you constantly. They bond deeply with their owners and can become very attached, sometimes to the point of jealousy or possessiveness. This intense attachment means Yorkies may struggle more with being left alone and can develop separation anxiety if not properly trained.
For first‑time owners who work outside the home regularly, the Shih Tzu’s slightly more independent nature may make alone‑time transitions easier. Owners who can be home most of the time and want an extremely devoted companion may appreciate the Yorkie’s intense loyalty.
Family Compatibility
With Children
Family compatibility is a crucial consideration for first‑time owners, especially those with children. Shih Tzus are excellent family pets, particularly well‑suited for households with children due to their gentle demeanor, sturdier build and tolerant nature. Their slightly larger size compared to Yorkies means they can handle gentle play from children without being as easily injured.
Yorkshire Terriers are not ideal for families with very young children due to their small, fragile bodies and tendency to be nippy or reactive around chaotic activity. Rough handling, even unintentionally, can injure them, and they may snap defensively if they feel threatened. Older children who understand how to be gentle are a better fit for Yorkies.
For first‑time dog owners with young children, the Shih Tzu is generally the safer and more appropriate choice. Families with older, responsible children can consider either breed, though the Shih Tzu’s calmer nature may still make daily life easier.
With Other Pets
Both breeds can coexist with other pets but require different approaches to introductions and ongoing management. Shih Tzus thrive on companionship and are often excellent with other pets in the home, including other dogs and cats, due to their friendly, non‑confrontational nature. They were not bred with prey drive and typically show little interest in chasing smaller animals.
Yorkshire Terriers carry terrier chase instincts and may pursue small animals, cats or even challenge much larger dogs. Their bold nature means they often do not recognize size differences and may pick fights with dogs many times their size. Careful introductions, supervision and management are essential, especially in homes with cats, rabbits or pocket pets.
For first‑time owners adding a dog to a home with existing pets, the Shih Tzu’s naturally sociable temperament makes integration smoother. Yorkie owners should plan for gradual introductions and ongoing supervision.
With Seniors and Single Owners
Both breeds can be excellent companions for seniors and single owners, though they suit different preferences. Shih Tzus are often recommended for seniors due to their calm nature, moderate exercise needs and friendly disposition. They do not require intense activity and are content with gentle walks and indoor companionship.
Yorkshire Terriers are extremely portable and bond intensely with single owners, making them ideal for people who want a constant companion they can take everywhere. However, their higher energy and barking may be more demanding for some seniors. Yorkies can also be carried easily due to their tiny size, which appeals to owners with mobility concerns.
Trainability and Behaviour Management
Learning Style and Intelligence
Both breeds are intelligent but approach training differently. Yorkshire Terriers are generally considered smarter and may prove easier to train for more commands, but their terrier stubbornness can make them challenging for first‑time owners. They are clever problem‑solvers but may use that intelligence to get what they want rather than comply with requests.
Shih Tzus are intelligent and usually take well to training, making them an ideal pet for first‑time owners. They are generally more willing to please and less likely to challenge authority, though they can be somewhat stubborn when they do not want to do something. Their calmer nature means training sessions can be shorter and more relaxed.
For first‑time owners, the Shih Tzu’s more compliant nature and lower energy often make training feel less overwhelming. Yorkie owners should expect to work harder on impulse control, barking management and establishing clear boundaries.
House‑Training Challenges
House‑training is a common concern for first‑time small dog owners, and both breeds present some challenges. Yorkshire Terriers are often reported as somewhat difficult to housebreak, requiring consistent effort, positive reinforcement and patience. Their small bladders and sometimes stubborn nature can extend the house‑training process.
Shih Tzus also require consistent training for house‑training success, but owners generally report they respond well to routine and positive reinforcement. Establishing a routine with consistent feeding times and immediately taking the dog outside to eliminate upon arrival helps establish good habits.
For both breeds, using indoor grass pads or frequent outdoor trips, especially for apartment dwellers, helps manage house‑training in small spaces.
Barking and Behaviour Issues
Managing unwanted behaviours is a significant part of owning either breed, though the specific issues differ. Yorkshire Terriers often develop “small dog syndrome” without proper boundaries, becoming bossy, demanding, barking excessively or snapping to get attention. Their vocal nature means barking management is often an ongoing project throughout their lives.
Shih Tzus are generally easier to manage behaviourally due to their calmer disposition and lower reactivity. They may still develop unwanted behaviours if under‑stimulated or spoiled, but these issues are typically less intense than Yorkie behavioural challenges.
For first‑time owners, the Shih Tzu’s lower tendency toward behavioural issues may make the early years of ownership less stressful.
Socialization Requirements
Early socialization is important for both breeds but critical for Yorkshire Terriers. Yorkies need extensive early exposure to new environments, sounds, people and other animals to prevent them from becoming overly suspicious, reactive or aggressive. Without proper socialization, their natural wariness can develop into fear‑based aggression or chronic anxiety.
Shih Tzus also benefit from socialization but are naturally more accepting of new experiences and people. Starting by gradually introducing your Shih Tzu to new environments, sounds and experiences helps them develop appropriate social skills, but they are generally less likely to develop serious behavioural problems from undersocialization.
For first‑time owners who may not have extensive experience with dog socialization, the Shih Tzu’s naturally sociable nature provides more margin for error.
Grooming and Coat Care
Coat Type and Shedding
Both breeds have distinctive coats that require significant maintenance, though the texture and care requirements differ somewhat. Shih Tzus have long, flowing double coats that are prone to tangling and matting, requiring daily brushing to keep them smooth and healthy. Many owners opt for a shorter “puppy cut” to reduce maintenance, though professional grooming is still required regularly.
Yorkshire Terriers have fine, silky single coats with a texture often compared to human hair. Like the Shih Tzu, Yorkie coats can be kept long and styled or clipped short for easier maintenance. Both coat types shed minimally compared to typical double‑coated breeds, which appeals to allergy‑conscious owners.
The key difference is texture: Yorkie fur is silky and fine, while Shih Tzu fur is more dense and prone to matting. Both require similar levels of grooming commitment.
Daily and Weekly Grooming Routines
Shih Tzus with long coats require daily brushing using a good‑quality wire brush with flexible pins, layering the hair to reach the skin. Many owners opt for professional grooming appointments every 4 to 6 weeks to prevent mats, maintain coat texture and promote healthy skin. Eye‑area hair should be tied up or trimmed to prevent irritation, and regular baths every 2 to 3 weeks help keep the coat clean.
Yorkshire Terriers also need daily brushing for long coats, with particular attention to high‑friction areas around the chest, ears, armpits and hindquarters. Professional grooming every 4 to 6 weeks plus baths, nail trims, ear cleaning and dental care remains essential. Many owners opt for shorter “puppy cuts” to reduce daily maintenance requirements.
For first‑time owners, the grooming commitment for both breeds is substantial and should not be underestimated. Budgeting both time and money for ongoing grooming is essential for either breed.
Professional Grooming Costs and Frequency
Both breeds are “grooming breeds” that require regular professional attention. Aim for grooming sessions every 4 to 6 weeks for both breeds to maintain coat health and prevent problems. Professional grooming costs vary by region but represent a recurring expense throughout the dog’s life.
Learning basic grooming skills at home can reduce costs but does not eliminate the need for professional grooming entirely. Skills like brushing, nail trimming, ear cleaning and hygiene trims between professional appointments help keep both breeds comfortable and healthy.
For first‑time owners on a budget, understanding that grooming costs are non‑negotiable for both breeds helps with realistic financial planning.
Grooming Temperament and Handling
Shih Tzus can be sensitive during grooming, so approaching each session with patience and gentle handling is essential. Creating a calm and comfortable environment and using positive reinforcement techniques such as treats and praise makes grooming a positive experience. Being mindful of the dog’s body language and taking breaks as needed ensures their comfort and well‑being.
Yorkshire Terriers may also be sensitive to grooming, particularly around the face, ears and paws. Their small size makes them easier to handle physically, but their sometimes stubborn nature may require patience during grooming sessions.
For first‑time owners, starting grooming routines early in the dog’s life and keeping sessions positive helps both breeds accept grooming as a normal part of life.
Allergy Considerations
Hypoallergenic Claims and Reality
Both breeds are often marketed as hypoallergenic or good for allergy sufferers, but the reality is more nuanced. No dog is truly 100% hypoallergenic, and individual reactions vary significantly based on the specific allergens that trigger symptoms. Dog allergies are caused by dander (a protein found in dead skin cells), saliva and urine, not by dog hair itself.
Shih Tzus have very low shedding, with the AKC ranking their shedding as one on a scale of one to five. However, the AKC does not include the Shih Tzu on its official list of hypoallergenic dog breeds, unlike Yorkshire Terriers, Poodles and Schnauzers. The difference is coat type: Shih Tzus have a double coat that may carry slightly more dander than single‑coated breeds.
Yorkshire Terriers appear on the AKC’s hypoallergenic breed list due to their single‑layered, human‑hair‑like coat that sheds minimally. Their fine coat may carry less dander when it does fall out, making them slightly more reliable for allergy sufferers.
Managing Allergies with Either Breed
For both breeds, additional steps can decrease exposure to allergens beyond choosing a low‑shedding coat. Regular bathing helps remove dander, though over‑bathing can dry the skin and cause irritation. Investing in a robot vacuum that runs daily picks up pet hair and dander, while HEPA air purifiers help remove allergens from the air.
Keeping the dog out of bedrooms, washing dog bedding frequently, and wiping down the coat after outdoor walks all help reduce allergen accumulation. Testing tolerance by spending time with each breed through breeders, rescues or friends before committing is strongly recommended where possible.
For first‑time owners with allergies, the Yorkshire Terrier’s single coat may be slightly more reliable, but both breeds can work for many allergy sufferers with proper management.
Health, Longevity and Veterinary Care
Lifespan Expectations
Both breeds are generally long‑lived compared to larger dogs, which is an important consideration for first‑time owners making a 10 to 15 year commitment. Shih Tzus have an average lifespan of around 12.7 years according to recent veterinary research, which is longer than the average of 11.2 years reported for dogs overall. Some Shih Tzus live well into their mid‑teens with proper care.
Yorkshire Terriers typically live between 12 and 16 years, with some individuals reaching the upper end of that range when well cared for. Their small size contributes to longevity, though certain health conditions can affect quality of life.
For first‑time owners, understanding that both breeds represent a long‑term commitment helps with realistic planning for veterinary care, grooming and lifestyle accommodation.
Shih Tzu Health Issues
Shih Tzus have specific health concerns that owners should monitor throughout their lives. The most common disorders affecting Shih Tzus include periodontal disease (affecting about 9.5% of Shih Tzus), anal sac impaction (7.4%) and ear disorders (5.5%). Several disorders increase in prevalence with age, including dental disease, heart murmur, keratoconjunctivitis sicca (dry eye) and ulcerative keratitis.
As a brachycephalic (flat‑faced) breed, Shih Tzus may experience breathing difficulties, though research suggests their overall health is much less severely compromised than other flat‑faced breeds like French Bulldogs. Eye problems are common due to their prominent eyes, including dry eye, corneal ulcers and tear staining.
The most common causes of death in Shih Tzus were bowel diseases (diarrhoea, vomiting etc.), heart disease and poor quality of life, each accounting for about 9.6% of deaths. Regular veterinary monitoring and preventive care help manage these conditions.
Yorkshire Terrier Health Issues
Yorkshire Terriers are prone to dental disease as their most frequent health complaint. A Yorkie’s jaw is incredibly small, and when adult teeth emerge, milk teeth frequently remain, causing overcrowding within the mouth and accumulation of food debris that leads to gum disease and bacterial growth. These bacteria can spread through the body and may ultimately damage the heart and liver.
Other common Yorkie health issues include patellar luxation (slipped kneecaps), tracheal collapse (weakening of the windpipe causing breathing difficulties), hypoglycemia (low blood sugar), and eye conditions such as cataracts or progressive retinal atrophy. Overgrown nails, anal sac impaction, obesity and persistent deciduous teeth are also commonly diagnosed.
Regular dental care including home brushing and professional cleanings is essential for Yorkies due to their high risk of dental disease. Weight management and careful monitoring of breathing are also important.
Veterinary Care and Prevention
For both breeds, preventive care is more cost‑effective and health‑protective than treating problems after they develop. Regular veterinary check‑ups, vaccinations, parasite prevention and dental care form the foundation of good health.
Oral hygiene is highlighted as a healthcare priority for both breeds, with daily brushing recommended to prevent periodontal disease. Feeding specific dental diets and providing dental chews can supplement brushing.
Pet insurance or dedicated savings for veterinary emergencies helps first‑time owners manage unexpected health costs over the dog’s long lifespan.
Exercise and Activity Requirements
Daily Exercise Needs
Exercise requirements differ significantly between these breeds and should match the owner’s lifestyle. Shih Tzus have less energy than most other dogs and are considered low‑energy dogs that still need regular stimulation but do not require intense activity. A long walk or two short walks daily, combined with some indoor play, typically meets their needs.
Yorkshire Terriers have a lot of energy and need more frequent activity to stay balanced. They benefit from multiple short walks, interactive play sessions and opportunities to explore. Without adequate exercise, Yorkies may become restless, vocal and destructive.
For first‑time owners with limited time for dog activities, the Shih Tzu’s lower exercise requirements may be more manageable. Active owners who enjoy walking and playing with their dogs may appreciate the Yorkie’s energy.
Mental Stimulation
Both breeds benefit from mental stimulation, though Yorkies typically need more to prevent boredom‑related behaviours. Yorkshire Terriers are intelligent and benefit from puzzle toys, training sessions, scent games and interactive play that engages their problem‑solving abilities.
Shih Tzus also enjoy mental enrichment but are generally content with less intensive stimulation. Short training sessions, gentle play and companionship typically satisfy their needs.
For first‑time owners, the Shih Tzu’s lower mental stimulation requirements may reduce the time commitment required.
Apartment and Small Space Living
Both breeds are excellent choices for apartment living due to their small size and moderate exercise needs. Shih Tzus are particularly well‑suited for small spaces due to their calm nature and lower energy levels. They do not need a yard and can meet their exercise needs through indoor play and short walks.
Yorkshire Terriers also fit well in apartments but their barking tendencies can be problematic in shared housing with thin walls. Managing barking through training and desensitization is essential for Yorkie apartment dwellers.
For first‑time owners in apartments or condos, the Shih Tzu’s quieter nature and lower energy make them the easier choice for maintaining good neighbour relations.
Cost of Ownership
Initial Costs
Both breeds involve significant initial costs beyond the purchase or adoption price. Purchasing from a responsible breeder costs more upfront but reduces the risk of genetic health problems and poor socialization. Rescue adoption fees are typically lower and offer the chance to give a home to a dog in need.
Initial expenses include crate, bed, collar, leash, bowls, food, first vet visit, vaccinations, microchipping and first grooming sessions. Quality supplies and early veterinary care help establish a foundation for long‑term health.
For first‑time owners, budgeting for initial costs beyond the purchase price prevents financial strain during the first weeks of ownership.
Ongoing Monthly Costs
Food costs are relatively low for both breeds due to their small size, but quality nutrition that supports dental health, coat condition and digestive function is worth the investment. Grooming, whether professional or home‑based with occasional salon visits, is a recurring expense for both breeds.
Veterinary check‑ups, vaccinations, parasite prevention, dental cleanings and emergency funds should be budgeted annually. Training classes, pet sitters and enrichment toys add to the cost for owners who work outside the home.
Over a 12 to 16 year lifespan, these expenses accumulate, and responsible ownership means planning for them from the start.
Long‑Term Financial Planning
Because both breeds often live longer than many large dogs, owners should plan for extended senior care including more frequent check‑ups, dental work and management of age‑related conditions. Health issues that develop with age, such as dental disease, heart problems and eye conditions, require ongoing veterinary attention.
Pet insurance or a dedicated savings buffer makes it easier to authorise best‑practice care when problems arise. Choosing a reputable breeder who prioritises health testing reduces the likelihood of genetic problems, though no breed is entirely free of risk.
Direct Comparison Table
| Aspect | Shih Tzu | Yorkshire Terrier |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 9–16 lbs, 8–11 inches tall | 7–10 lbs, 8–9 inches tall |
| Energy level | Low; calm and relaxed | High; active and lively |
| Barking tendency | Low; quieter than most breeds | High; frequent barker |
| Temperament | Friendly, gentle, people-oriented | Bold, feisty, loyal, sometimes bossy |
| With children | Good with all ages when supervised | Better with older, gentle children |
| With other pets | Generally excellent | May chase; needs management |
| Trainability | Good; willing to please | Smart but stubborn |
| First-time owner suitability | Excellent; widely recommended | Moderate; requires more management |
| Grooming needs | High; daily brushing, professional grooming | High; daily brushing, professional grooming |
| Allergy friendliness | Low shedding but not AKC-classified hypoallergenic | Low shedding; AKC-listed hypoallergenic |
| Common health issues | Periodontal disease, anal sac issues, eye and ear concerns | Dental disease, patellar luxation, tracheal concerns |
| Lifespan | Average 12.7 years | 12–16 years |
| Exercise needs | Low; one long or two short walks daily | Moderate-high; multiple walks and play |
| Apartment suitability | Excellent; quiet and calm | Good with barking management |
Which Breed Suits Which Owner?
Choose a Shih Tzu If You Want
A Shih Tzu is the better choice for first‑time owners who want a calm, affectionate companion that does not require intense exercise or constant stimulation. This breed suits owners who value peace and quiet in shared housing, have young children who need a tolerant, sturdy dog, or simply prefer a relaxed companion over an energetic one.
Shih Tzus are particularly well‑suited for seniors, apartment dwellers and families seeking a gentle first dog. Their friendly nature makes them easy to take to social situations, and their lower energy means less time commitment for exercise.
The grooming commitment is significant, so be prepared for daily brushing and regular professional grooming costs.
Choose a Yorkshire Terrier If You Want
A Yorkshire Terrier is the better choice for owners who want a tiny dog with a big, expressive personality and can accept the vocal, attention‑seeking behaviours that come with the terrier temperament. This breed suits owners who enjoy active engagement, training sessions and interactive play, and who can manage barking through consistent training.
Yorkies are ideal for single owners or couples who want an extremely devoted companion they can take everywhere, including travel. Their tiny size makes them extremely portable, fitting easily into carrier bags and meeting airline cabin requirements.
Be prepared for more management around barking, socialization and establishing clear boundaries to prevent “small dog syndrome.”
Special Considerations for First‑Time Owners
First‑time small dog owners often underestimate the training and management required for toy breeds. Both breeds need consistent boundaries, regular grooming and appropriate socialization to become well‑adjusted companions.
The Shih Tzu’s calmer temperament and friendlier nature provide more margin for first‑time owner mistakes. Yorkies require more experience with training and behaviour management, though motivated first‑time owners can succeed with proper research and commitment.
Whichever breed you choose, investing in early training, proper socialization and regular veterinary care sets the foundation for a rewarding long‑term relationship.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which breed is better for first‑time dog owners?
Shih Tzus are generally considered better for first‑time owners due to their calm temperament, lower energy, reduced barking and friendlier nature. Around 89% of experienced Shih Tzu owners recommend the breed for beginners. Yorkshire Terriers can work for motivated first‑time owners but require more management around barking and behaviour.
Which breed barks more?
Yorkshire Terriers bark significantly more than Shih Tzus due to their terrier heritage and watchdog instincts. Shih Tzus were bred as companions and typically have little reason to bark, making them much quieter in apartments and shared housing.
Are Shih Tzus or Yorkies better with children?
Shih Tzus are generally better with children of all ages due to their gentle nature, sturdier build and tolerant temperament. Yorkshire Terriers are fragile and may be nippy with young children, making them better suited for families with older, gentle kids.
Which breed is more hypoallergenic?
Yorkshire Terriers appear on the AKC’s hypoallergenic breed list while Shih Tzus do not, though both are low‑shedding breeds. Yorkies have single‑layered, human‑hair‑like coats that may carry slightly less dander. However, individual reactions vary, and neither breed is truly 100% hypoallergenic.
How much exercise does each breed need?
Shih Tzus are low‑energy dogs needing one long walk or two short walks daily plus some indoor play. Yorkshire Terriers have higher energy and need multiple walks plus interactive play and mental stimulation.
Which breed is easier to train?
Shih Tzus are generally easier to train for first‑time owners due to their calmer nature and willingness to please. Yorkshire Terriers are intelligent but stubborn, requiring more patience and consistency.
Do both breeds require professional grooming?
Yes, both breeds require regular professional grooming every 4 to 6 weeks plus daily brushing at home. Neither breed is low‑maintenance in terms of coat care.
Which breed lives longer?
Both breeds are long‑lived, with Shih Tzus averaging around 12.7 years and Yorkshire Terriers typically living 12 to 16 years. Proper care and preventive health measures can help both breeds reach the upper end of their life expectancy.
What are the main health concerns for each breed?
Shih Tzus commonly face periodontal disease, anal sac impaction, ear disorders and eye problems. Yorkshire Terriers are particularly prone to dental disease, patellar luxation, tracheal collapse and eye conditions. Both breeds require regular dental care.
Can either breed be left alone during work hours?
Both breeds can tolerate being alone for moderate periods with proper training, but neither thrives being ignored all day. Yorkshire Terriers may develop separation anxiety more easily due to their intense attachment to owners. Dog walkers, daycare or family support help when owners work long hours.
Which breed is better for apartment living?
Both breeds are excellent for apartments due to their small size, but Shih Tzus are often the easier choice due to their calm nature and lower barking tendency. Yorkshire Terriers fit well in apartments but require barking management to maintain good neighbour relations.
Are these breeds good for seniors?
Both breeds can be excellent for seniors. Shih Tzus are often recommended due to their calm nature and moderate exercise needs. Yorkshire Terriers are extremely portable and bond intensely with single owners but may be more demanding in terms of energy and barking.
How do these breeds get along with other pets?
Shih Tzus are generally excellent with other pets due to their friendly, non‑confrontational nature. Yorkshire Terriers may chase small animals and challenge larger dogs due to their terrier instincts, requiring careful introductions and supervision.
What is the price difference between these breeds?
Prices vary significantly by region, breeder reputation and lineage, but both breeds typically fall in similar price ranges when purchased from responsible breeders. Rescue adoption fees are generally lower for both breeds.
Which breed has a better temperament overall?
“Better” depends on owner preference. Shih Tzus have a calmer, friendlier temperament suited to those wanting a relaxed companion. Yorkshire Terriers have a bold, lively temperament suited to those wanting an expressive, devoted companion who keeps them entertained.
Which breed is better for apartment living Shih Tzu or Yorkshire Terrier
Shih Tzus are generally the better choice for apartment living due to their calmer temperament, lower energy levels and significantly quieter nature compared to Yorkshire Terriers.
Why Shih Tzus Excel in Apartments
Shih Tzus were bred specifically as companion lap dogs for Chinese royalty, which shaped their temperament to be calm, adaptable and content simply being near their owners. They are described as ideal for apartment living because their small size means they need less space to run around, and their low exercise needs make them especially suitable for smaller homes. A small size dog like a Shih Tzu requires only daily walks and short play sessions to stay physically and mentally stimulated.
One of the most significant advantages for apartment dwellers is that Shih Tzus are known for being relatively quiet compared to other breeds, making them a great choice for situations where excessive barking can be an issue. Some owners report that their Shih Tzu rarely barks at all. This quiet nature helps maintain good relationships with neighbours in shared housing.
Yorkshire Terrier Challenges in Apartments
Yorkshire Terriers are far more active and bark much more than Shih Tzus due to their terrier heritage and watchdog instincts. Yorkies have a history of being barkers and will alert to strangers, noises in hallways, delivery people and any activity outside windows. One apartment owner reported that their Yorkie “barks so loud that he sounds like he’s being abused” and “screams every time I leave,” which can be problematic in apartment complexes.
While Yorkies can adapt to apartment living and make excellent watchdogs, proper training and socialization are necessary when they are still puppies to limit their barking and distrust of new people. Managing Yorkie barking requires consistent training, desensitization to triggers and realistic expectations, as the behaviour is deeply rooted in their breed history.
Quick Comparison for Apartment Living
Both breeds can live happily in apartments, but Shih Tzus require less management and pose fewer noise-related challenges. For first-time apartment dwellers or those with noise-sensitive neighbours, the Shih Tzu’s naturally quieter disposition makes daily life considerably easier.
Smart Pet Care Information Hub
Explore essential pet care information — from nutrition and exercise routines to first aid and seasonal health tips. Empower yourself with the knowledge your pet deserves.